
Immigration has been a subject of national debate lately. As an immigrant myself, I don't think anything I say can be construed as independent. However, NYTimes columnist John Tierney has this nice piece called Angels in America(subscription required) where he says,
I'd like to see Republicans on Capitol Hill explain to Espinoza why he's less deserving than their immigrant ancestors, but that's probably too much to expect.
This discussion also reminded me of a post I made on the Hetergenius blog, a revised version of which is posted below:
The notion of being an American, for most of the world outside of America, has been that of being part of an egalitarian, merit-based society, where-in hardwork is rewarded, and entreprenuership treasured, making it a fertile land for personal achievement. For the longest time, the bulk of the immigrant workforce came from Europe and from Mexico and perhaps some from China. However, the latter half of the 20th century, especially after the civil rights movement, combined with America's increased involvement with world affairs, led to a huge influx from East, South East Asia, and the Middle East. Like other immigrant groups before, these groups contributed immensly to the American economy and culture saving America from the late of Old Europe (I guess Rummy wasn't wrong).
But unfortunately, if Newsweeks' Fareed Zakaria is to be believed, not only do we scare the world, we are also scaring off prospective Americans. And if Alan Greenspan is to be believed, we need immigration if we are to grow as an economy and support the coming wave of baby boomer retirement. In fact Greenspan is pretty lucid when he says,
... immigration, if we choose to expand it, could also lessen the decline of labor force growth in the United States. As the influx of foreign workers that occurred in response to the tight labor markets of the 1990s demonstrated, U.S. immigration does respond to evolving economic conditions. But to fully offset the effects of the decline in fertility, immigration would have to be much larger than almost all current projections assume.
So to all the conservative folks, so drunk with their recent successes and blinded by their hawkish world view, I would say, be open to other people, and and their cultures, or like Germany, we'll be stuck with mammoth government machinery, that when starved for fresh ideas, will ultimately end up feeding on itself.
Recent Comments